Chronicles of Community-Driven Research: The Evolution of MEBO and PATM Studies

In the ever-evolving landscape of medical science, the untangling of medical mysteries often hinges not just on technological advancements or expert researchers, but on the active involvement of community members. Community efforts have been instrumental in the identification and understanding of elusive conditions MEBO (Metabolic Body Odor) and PATM (People Are Allergic to Me).

Late 1990s - early 2000s: The Dawn of Online Support Forums 

Before the conditions were officially named, online forums like MSN Body Odor Support Forum, ibsgroup.org, Yahoo TMAU group, and Curezone BO & Halitosis and TMAU forums served as early platforms for sufferers to discuss their symptoms. 

At this time, Trimethylaminuria (TMAU) was a scarcely recognized condition, and diagnostic tests were both costly and geographically limited. Trimethylaminuria support group, later established as foundation raises 35K and awards it to Dr. George Preti of Monell Center, the world’s only independent, non-profit scientific institute dedicated to interdisciplinary basic research on the senses of taste and smell.

2006-2007: Birth of MEBO and PATM Communities

In 2006, the acronym "PATM" was first coined by a sufferer, and by 2007, a dedicated PATM community was established on MedHelp. The initial post was reposted in PATM forum and garnered over 8,800 responses, signifying the start of a community-led initiative to explore the condition. While the term FBO (fecal body odor) emerged earlier and is still used on online forums,  it is often avoided due to its less appealing connotation. MEBO was coined by another individual suffering from a similar undiagnosed condition. This further fueled community-driven research and knowledge sharing among those affected.

2008: Broadening the Dialogue

The blog Bloodbornebodyodorandhalitosis.com is launched, later transitioned to meboblog.com. This year also saw more in-person meetups and community surveys, including one by pharmacist Arun Nagrath that received about 100 responses. 95% of responders was trying to seek medical help, over 90% thought that their doctor was not knowledgeable nor confident in their recommendations. 

2009: Formalizing Research Efforts

MEBO Research Charity was founded in both the UK and Florida, spearheaded by Maria de la Torre. The first collaborative study with UK's Biolab was initiated, focusing on blood and urine tests. The results were subsequently published on the MEBO blog and clinicaltrials.gov (NCT02692495, principal investigator: Irene Gabashvili).

2010: Unveiling the Microbiome and Genetic Factors

At MEBO's 1st annual conference, held in Nashville, Dr. Gabashvili presents "Microbes and us," discussing the human microbiome's role in poorly understood conditions like idiopathic malodor and multiple chemical sensitivities (MCS). Previously, MEBO interviewed Metametrix about their GI Effects panel, which measured stool bacteria, fungus, and parasites with DNA analysis.  Metametrix, pioneer in diagnostics of nutritional insufficiencies and metabolic dysfunction,was later acquired by Genova Diagnostics.

Dr. Nigel Manning introduces 12 potential subtypes of TMAU. Out of 1,150 urine samples from 716 individuals collected between 1997 and 2009, 379 (53%) indicate significant TMAU presence. The launch of a new FMO3 genetic testing service promises to provide clearer diagnostic results. Additionally, a TMAU service dog program is initiated.

2011: The Advent of Genomic Data Sharing

Community members begin sharing genomic data, and MEBO critiques the limitations of 23andMe's FMO3 testing in blog posts. Dr. George Preti and his team at the Monell Center publish "Individuals reporting idiopathic malodor production: demographics and incidence of trimethylaminuria", revealing that only one-third of individuals with idiopathic malodor test positive for TMAU. New study from Oxford, proposes two genes coding enzymes, besides FMO3, NAT8 and PYROXD2, both with relatively uncharacterized functional roles, as potentially linked to TMAU. 

The second annual meetup in Washington, DC, focuses on the interplay between genetic mechanisms and holistic health. Skype conference call group is formed. 

2012: Empowering Patients Through Technology

A new MEBO study focusing on alveolar breath is initiated (NCT03451994). Aurametrix health management software is publicly launched, allowing patients to diagnose metabolic inefficiencies through digital food and symptom journaling. Karen James, MEBO UK’s Public Relations Director, publishes an article in the Royal College of General Practitioners (RCGP) journal InnovAiT, describing the life of a TMAU sufferer. For iGEM competition,  student team from Fatih university genetically engineers bacteria producing geraniol and FMO3 to eliminate TMA odors. Their product, FreshEcoli, is supposed to work as a synthetic perfume. 

The Third Annual Meetup in Miami Beach features Dr. Elizabeth Shephard discussing pharmacogenetics and personalized medicine.

2013: Deepening Theoretical Insights

MEBO UK's scientific director, Dr. Colin Harvey-Woodworth, publishes an article proposing that some MEBO symptoms may be secondary to dimethylsulphidemia, a previously unidentified metabolic condition linked to DMGDH gene. Concurrently, a mediterranean study reveals that individuals carrying FMO3 mutations may not necessarily experience odor issues. The study finds that the TMA/TMAO ratio in urine samples from individuals with 158KK/308EG variants indicates reduced FMO3 activity, yet these individuals do not exhibit the hallmark fish-like odor commonly associated with trimethylaminuria. This data underscores the notion that the expression of trimethylaminuria symptoms is influenced by factors beyond the presence of specific genetic variants.

2014: Therapeutic Innovations

Dr. Jean-François Brugère proposes the therapeutic use of archaea to prevent trimethylaminuria and cardiovascular disease. The technique was patented but not yet tested in humans. MEBO's TMAU urine testing program is initiated, and the results  are discussed. Another student team from Paris University, genetically engineers skin bacteria by introducing a trimethylamine mono-oxygenase from a non-human bacteria Ruegeria pomeroyi, for iGEM competition. Dr. Aydin proposes new definitions for halitosis. Reddit TMAU and PATM groups are created. 

2015: Expanding Testing and new molecular targets

The MEBO Conference in Orlando distributes urine test kits based on choline challenges and discusses emerging trends in testing methodologies.

3,3-Dimethyl-1-butanol (DMB), which is a structural analog of choline found in some foods, such as balsamic vinegars, red wines, some cold-pressed extra virgin olive oils and grapeseed oils is demonstrated to inhibit TMA production by gut bacteria. DMB has potential as a therapeutic approach. Studies also show the inhibitory effects of Resveratrol on TMA production in mice, further expanding the scope of potential small molecule targets. Dr Stanley Hazen files a patent.

2016: Streamlining Diagnostic Approaches

MEBO collaborates with Professor David Wishart on a Urine Metabolomics study, registered as NCT02683876, involving Canadian participants. The study aims to explore simpler, non-challenge-based tests for diagnosis.

Several sufferers in the MEBO community report taking Resveratrol for a few months, with excellent results in decreasing or completely eliminating their odor symptoms while increasing consumption of foods high in choline, carnitine, and lecithin.

2017: Diagnostic Breakthroughs and the Social Media Shift

MEBO's Scientific Director, Irene Gabashvili, publishes the Biolab study on BiorXiv. The study reveals significant differences in intestinal permeability among participants based on body regions responsible for VOC emissions. In addition, the study identifies two subgroups of MEBO/PATM sufferers based on sugar intake. Due to the small sample size of 16 participants, the article remains a preprint. Unfortunately, the current structure and incentives of mainstream academic publishing favor well-funded research on common diseases and are less accommodating to research on overlooked rare conditions. 

A Monell Center Study published in BMC Medical Genetics delves into the genetic complexities of TMAU, revealing that not all cases are linked to the FMO3 gene. Although the choline challenge test confirmed a diagnosis of TMAU by revealing a high level of urinary TMA in all 10 subjects, genetic analyses revealed that the FMO3 gene appeared to be normal in four of the 10. Additional analyses revealed defects in several other genes that could contribute to the inability to metabolize the odorous TMA. No rare variants are found in PYROXD2 and a DMGDH, but there were associations with BHMT2, SARDH and SHMT1 genes, which directly interact with DMGDH in the gene network and may participate in the same pathway. At MEBO conference in Miami Beach, Professor Shephard talks about microbiome and diet. 

Armpit microbiome transplantation shows reduction in odor when performed from one sibling to another. 

Danny Kunz and his Citizen Research Group in Germany initiate a DNA sequencing study. Their simulations backed by large enzyme databases suggest that Thyroid-stimulating hormone (TSH) may play a role. Danny proposes a new name for the condition: Intestinal Metabolic Bromhidrosis Syndrome (IMBS).

TMAU UP Podcast is launched on YouTube. Facebook's "Groups" feature spurs the creation of new private MEBO and PATM communities, marking a new era in community engagement and data sharing.

2018-2020: Advancing Research and Understanding

A Microbiome study of MEBO and PATM communities is initiated, registered as NCT02683876. 

A Japanese paper confirms PATM as a physical condition connected to skin petrochemicals and microbes. Meanwhile a case report entitled "People allergic to me and body dysmorphic disorder" published in Asian Journal of Psychiatry is linking a case to a relatively common psychiatric disorder characterized by preoccupations with perceived defects in physical appearance. The average age of BDD onset was previously estimated as 15 with symptoms lasting 18 years on average without proper treatment. The prevalence of BDD is thought to be 0.7-2.4% in the general population, but the condition remains underdiagnosed and poorly understood.

Results from the MEBO-Wishart study align with previous MEBO/PATM findings but highlight the limitations of morning urine tests. A new PATM survey is conducted by an independent PATM ufferer/researcher. Average age of responders is 28. Mononucleosis due to CMV is proposed as the cause of PATM.

A UC San Diego student team explores the enzymatic breakdown of TMA. New gene SELENBP1 is proposed to explain metabolic halitosis. A patent on using Mikania plant extract to inhibit the conversion of choline to trimethylamine (TMA) is filed and granted, based on an earlier patent for using this plant to suppress body odor. 

RareConnect is established as a platform for those affected by rare diseases, including MEBO Research members. MEBO Research becomes a member. Unfortunately, by the end of 2023 it will be shut down, not being able to compete with Facebook and Reddit. Yahoo Groups shut down on December 15, 2020, for the same reason. New Instagram and WhatsApp groups are created.

New paper "Treatments of trimethylaminuria: where we are and where we might be heading" is published. It reviews Fecal microbial transplantation (FMT) that was not especially successful for reducing TMA or was only transiently effective as the symptoms returned one year after treatment. Antibiotic treatment is also transiently effective in some patients and completely ineffective in others.  Future research directions include gene therapy, enzyme replacement/enhancement therapy and gut microbiome modulation. 

Peer-reviewed paper examining the microbiome traits of individuals self-identifying with PATM and MEBO (NCT02683876) is published in JMIR Dermatology. The study reveals that both MEBO and PATM share increased levels of malodor-associated skin bacteria compared to non-MEBO/non-PATM groups, correlating with severity of self-reported symptoms. However, both populations exhibit significant heterogeneity.

2021-2023: Ongoing Challenges and Future Directions

A COVID study identifies flare-ups in 10-15% of the MEBO population post-infection and vaccination, possibly related to microbiome and hormonal fluctuations (NCT04832932; peer-reviewed paper published in JMIR Formative Research). COVID-19 has led to the emergence of new cases, with individuals developing MEBO/PATM conditions following infection and/or vaccination.

A cysteine challenge test for hydrogen sulfide production is suggested. Florida State University's iGem team proposes a synthetic biology project for TMAU. 

New paper by Chris Callewaert explores various cutting-edge approaches to skin health, including genetically engineered probiotics and microbiome transplantation. While promising, the latter method currently lacks scalability for industrial applications. The paper also delves into skin bacteriotherapy, a technique involving the application of one or multiple pure bacterial cultures with health-promoting properties to cleansed or disinfected skin areas. Additionally, the study examines the use of prebiotics applied directly to the skin to encourage the growth of beneficial microbes. Each of these innovative approaches holds promise but also presents its own set of challenges.

A study by Professor Sekine in Nature Scientific Reports identifies volatile organic compounds as key differentiators between PATM sufferers and controls. These results align with our yet to be published findings from MEBO-Menssana Alveolar Breath Test Study (NCT03451994) and Microbiome study (NCT03582826). 

The FSU team introduces their innovative probiotic, E.esperance, at the iGEM competition in Paris on November 2, 2023.

Despite these advancements, mainstream science remains largely uninterested in community-based research, leaving MEBO, PATM and TMAU without a definitive cure.

Human Skin Gas Profiles in PATM

People Allergic to Me (PATM) is a perplexing condition that has left both sufferers and medical professionals searching for answers. Thousands of individuals worldwide claim to experience PATM, leading to severe mental health challenges such as depression, anxiety, and suicidal tendencies. Despite its far-reaching impact, the underlying causes remain mysterious, with only a few scientific studies dedicated to understanding this condition. While a small subset of PATM sufferers has been diagnosed with TMAU, the majority remain without a diagnosis. 

A new study lead by Professor Sekine, recently published in Nature Scientific Reports, explores the human skin gas profiles to shed new light on PATM. 

The study included 44 subjects, divided into two groups: 24 without PATM (non-PATM) and 20 with PATM. The non-PATM group involved 13 male and 11 female participants (age: 18–59, 31 ± 13 years old). The PATM group comprised 12 male and 8 female participants (age: 19–53, average 39 ± 12 years old).

The non-PATM group had no known diseases, while the PATM group reported symptoms of PATM without other apparent diseases.

Researchers sought to understand the skin gas profile of people with and without PATM, potentially the source of body odor or other types of emissions. They measured the emission rate of 75 volatile compounds from the skin using a tool called a passive flux sampler (PFS) coupled with gas chromatography/mass spectrometry (GC/MS). PFS was designed to be convenient and unobtrusive, allowing people to use it on the go without any hassle.

Participants in the study were given a PFS device, similar in size to a bottle cap, to collect skin gas samples from their non-dominant forearm. They wore this device for an hour without any restrictions on their activities. The device was easily attached to the skin with a piece of surgical tape and didn't require any special preparation. After collecting the samples, PFS devices were sent to the laboratory and analyzed.

The PATM group exhibited significantly greater emission fluxes for a variety of chemicals, including some with offensive odors, and lower emissions of others, including some with more pleasant or neutralizing smells. 

Among the 75 measured skin gases, the PATM group exhibited significantly greater emission fluxes for chemicals like alcohol 2-ethyl-1-hexanol (2E1H), aldehyde isovaleraldehyde, hexanal, acetone, toluene, m,p-xylene, methyl mercaptan, ethyl mercaptan, and allyl methyl sulphide (AMS). These chemicals often have offensive odors and/or can lead to adverse health effects. The emissions of petrochemical 2E1H, and aromatic hydrocarbons (with benzene ring in their structure): toluene, and m,p-xylene were notably higher in the PATM group, with increases of approximately 12, 39, and four times, respectively.

Volatile organosulfur compounds such as methyl mercaptan (fecal odor, resembling smell of rotten cabbage or decaying vegetables), ethyl mercaptan (rotten fish, garlic, or onions), and Allyl Methyl Sulfide (AMS, garlic- or onion-like odor) were also significant. These compounds have extremely low odor thresholds and could easily alter body odor perception in PATM subjects. Bacteria in the oral cavity, such as Porphyromonas gingivalis and Anaerobic bacteria in the gut, such as Desulfovibrio species are producers of Methanethiol. 

Isovaleraldehyde contributes to body odor with a pungent fruit-like smell that can also contribute to aroma of beer and cheese. It can be sourced from metabolic breakdown of amino acids like leucine and valine, hence dietary intake, and microbial activity in the gut by methylotrophic yeasts. , species of Clostridium, Actinobacteria (Rhodococcus, Mycobacterium and Gordonia), Proteobacteria (Acetobacterium such as Gluconobacter oxydans), Odoribacteraceae, Ruminococcus gnavus, etc. These microbes are capable of producing  Isovaleraldehyde through anaerobic fermentation and the mevalonate-independent glyceraldehyde 3-phosphate/pyruvate pathway. 

Greater emission of acetone might indicate eating disorders in the PATM group, as it is influenced by fasting, starvation, or diet.

The PATM group had less skin release of various substances, including some types of alcohols, smell-related chemicals, and fruity-smelling compounds. Some of these chemicals are used in flavors or fragrances and are known to have a relaxing effect.

For example, α-pinene, β-pinene, and D-limonene have antifungal activities as well as abilities to decrease depression-like behavior and improve memory via an anti-neuroinflammatory mechanism under chronic restraint stress. 

D-limonene can be consumed through the diet by eating citrus fruits or drinking citrus-flavored beverages. Some fruity-smelling compounds are naturally found in fruits like peach and pineapple and contribute to sweet body scents. It can also be absorbed through the skin from personal care products containing citrus oils or inhaled from air.

Acetic acid smells like vinegar and is made by bacteria breaking down certain substances in sweat. It is linked to body odor in young adults. Lower skin emissions of acetic acid in the PATM group showed that sweating may not be the cause of their unique body odor. Acetic Acid is produced by acetic acid bacteria, such as Acetobacter and Gluconobacter species. Certain lactic acid bacteria, such as Lactobacillus, can also produce acetic acid.

The study also looked at benzaldehyde, which might come from toluene. People with PATM had much more skin emission of toluene but less of benzaldehyde.

The presence of benzaldehyde in the human body is typically at low levels, and its occurrence may vary based on factors such as diet, environmental exposure, individual metabolism, and gut microbiome composition. Almonds, apricots, and cherries are examples of foods that contain benzaldehyde or related compounds. Toluene is a common solvent used in various industrial and household products such as paints, glues, nail polish, and cleaning agents. Inhalation of fumes from these products can lead to toluene being present in the blood and tissues.

The ratio of toluene to benzaldehyde was much higher in the PATM group, and this ratio is seen as a key sign of PATM.

Air quality in terms of petrochemicals is worse in urban areas, high traffic areas, industrial workspaces, poorly ventilated interiors, newly constructed or renovated spaces, automotive interiors, salons and beauty parlors, households using cleaning products containing petrochemicals, such as certain detergents, aerosol sprays, and solvents, spaces with indoor smoking and even some healthcare facilities. 

Our previous study on breath VOC profiles in PATM, TMAU and MEBO (Alveolar Breath Test Study registered as NCT03451994) has unveiled intriguing insights into petrochemical metabolism, indicating that non-TMAU MEBO population may have difficulties with metabolizing environmental pollutants, while the Microbiome study (registered as NCT03582826) uncovered possible microbial sources of compounds that differentiate PATM, TMAU and MEBO from non-MEBO & non-PATM populations. Our findings align remarkably with Professor Sekine's work.

The synergy between these discoveries is shedding light on the underlying mechanisms and potential diagnostic markers. We will be publishing these complementary results soon, further contributing to the scientific community's knowledge of PATM, TMAU and MEBO.

Stay tuned for our upcoming publications, as we continue to unravel the mysteries of these conditions, working towards a future where this condition is better understood, diagnosed, and managed. 

REFERENCES

Sekine Y, Oikawa D, Todaka M. Human skin gas profile of individuals with the people allergic to me phenomenon. Sci Rep. 2023 Jun 10;13(1):9471. doi: 10.1038/s41598-023-36615-1. PMID: 37301918; PMCID: PMC10257688.